Style Jacker: Paris Hilton or Sarah Carroll?

I knew this dress looked familiar when I put together the post for the Victoria's Secret "What is Sexy?" party. Turns out Paris Hilton wore this Risto Bimbiloski dress just days earlier at the Nylon Young Hollywood party and not too long after actress Sarah Carroll sported the same one down the red carpet. Who do you think wore it better? While it's a very cute dress, and both ladies look great, I think it makes Paris look big (for once!). But I do prefer her shoes and accessories over Sarah's. What do you think?