Fashion Faceoff: Ciara vs. Joan Smalls?

I love this dress so much! I love a LBD and this is a good one...but very hard to pull off. So which lady pulled off the Balmain Resort 2013 dress better--Ciara or [Supermodel] Joan Smalls?

Ciara wore hers with Christian Louboutin camouflage "Daf" boots

And Joan wore her's with Christian Louboutin fishnet corset “Attention” boots